Prof. Sen! Modi’s also won the battle of ideas.

Though the recent emphatic victories of Modi-led BJP in various elections since 2014 are very much part of the global rise of the far-right phenomena, however, we must not reduce Mr Modi’s winning spree as mere onward march of right-wing populism or a result of effective campaign machinery and strategy or, worse, an outcome of weak opposition. I have talked about the populism etc. in my response to Aatish Taseer’s article on Modi in the Time magazine.

Since we have a plethora of analyses and commentaries of all hues out there, there is no need to elaborate. But I would like to comment on the opinion of Prof Amartya Sen published in the NYT.

107096948_result_map_2019_640-ncAccording to Prof Sen, ’[T]hat is victory in terms of power but not in the battle of ideas.’ It is not only a lethargic understanding of the situation, but also a naive one. I am sorry to say this for I have a great respect for him and his scholarship. His general remarks related to electioneering, pumping of huge money, misuse of the state-owned media and the surge of nationalism in the past months are well taken. His regret regarding the Opposition not paying the required attention to the ‘battle of ideas’, his emphasis on the rectification of the same and his call for a greater engagement are also very important.

But, must I say, Prof Sen himself has missed a chance to initiate an engagement.

We must remind ourselves that the idea of Hindutva championed by Savarkar and the RSS has been a consistent presence in the battle since the early decennia of the last century. The contending idea/s may make a comeback sooner or later, but the reality, as of today, is the Hindutva brand of politics is the champion. One should also note that its influence is larger than its electoral victories and vote shares.

In this context, I would recommend the synoptic commentary of Prof Purushottam Agrawal published in the Outlook.

He underlines, and I quote a full paragraph, ‘[T]he single most important factor of BJP’s stunning victory is the projection of a national vision, a shared dream of proud, assertive India, and its success in presenting (with eager help from the worthies in TV newsrooms) the opposition, in particular the Congress, as indifferent, if not hostile to proud Indian nationalism. Let us not forget that an emotional connect with past and a concern with future plays a crucial role in all societies. This patriotic sentiment can be articulated either in a regressive, bigoted hyper-nationalism or in democratic, inclusive nationalism. Academic debates on various aspects of nationalism may go on, but in everyday politics, the power of nationalism can hardly be denied.’

Whenever one discusses the BJP’s electoral performances, he or she has to refer the Modi-Shah duo. It has been a pattern for sometime. But, in the recently concluded elections, a third presence has joined the limelight- Pragya Thakur. This noun does not merely represent an individual. It is a predilection. Her dovetailing by the BJP is a clear sign of the party’s bumptious arrival. Prof Sen and Prof Agrawal have discussed her.

Referring to her statement on Gandhi’s assassin and the response of the BJP, Prof Sen says, ’[T]his embarrassed even the B.J.P., which made her formally apologize.’ Prof Agrawal writes, ‘[H]er endorsement of Godse as a “patriot forever” had apparently upset PM Modi so much that he is not going to ever forgive her in his heart. The right noises and right actions were there from top to bottom; and then there were these full-throated endorsement of the man hanged for killing Gandhi’

Let us mark the difference in the two understandings of the Pragya Thakur episode. Prof Sen perceives the situation as the BJP would like to, but Prof Agarawal uses the word ‘apparently.’ His observation becomes clearer in the next sentence he puts in to begin the next paragraph. He underlines, and rightly so, ‘[T]his is chemistry of coded communication which works so effectively within the Sangh Parivar due to a shared vision.’

Since the RSS-BJP combine represents a vision and drives an idea, we must concede that the saffron has triumphed. Prof Agrawal is right when he says, referring to 2014, ‘[I]t was not a mere regime change, it was the culmination of “five generations’ sustained work” and beginning of using the state apparatus to consolidate the alternative idea of India. It was no more business as usual.’

Conceding this does not mean that the other idea- an inclusive India based on the constitutional values and progressiveness- is redundant or not relevant or we should shun it. In fact, we have to re-invent and re-energies those very ideas.

(Published on on May 28, 2019)

3 thoughts on “Prof. Sen! Modi’s also won the battle of ideas.

Add yours

  1. Well appreciated reply! Kudos to you! I think the other factors which may be worthy of being mentioned are the changing nature of the social contract of the lower middle class with the state in the neo- liberal setting.Having got accustomed to the individual as the epicentre of new unleashing of economic forces, the substandard furnishing of the services by the state, deep in the morass of corruption is hardly welcomed.The nature of the security dimensions of the state needs to be forged with some cogent alternative to the prevailing masculine one. There are external factors also which are shaped by the international politics.And much more….!!


  2. I quite agree with Mr Purushotam Agarwal’s analysis. I don’t share the euphoria in most sections on Mr Modi’s address to NDA friends in parliament House. Mr Modi knows what he is doing. He also made quite a few busy and many mesmerised with his digital camera, cloud cover, eMail, and Alexander in Bihar, and so on.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Create a website or blog at

Up ↑

%d bloggers like this: